Death in Shambles
In Stephen Alter’s mystery novel Death in Shambles, the protagonist Lionel Carmichael, a retired police officer, embarks on a murder investigation in a small hill town nestled in the mountains of Uttarakhand. The book pays homage to Agatha Christie, particularly her Miss Marple stories, with its small-town setting and retired detective protagonist.
While the familiar elements of a Christie-esque whodunit are present, Death in Shambles takes a darker and more noir approach. The decrepit and sleazy Shambala Villa, owned by the self-proclaimed godman Reuben Sabharwal, sets the tone for the story. When Reuben is found stabbed to death in his kitchen, Carmichael delves into the seedy world surrounding the cult-like atmosphere of the villa.
Alter skillfully evokes the atmosphere of the small hill town, capturing its charm, religious fervor, and the stark divide between the wealthy and the poor. The characters are vividly portrayed, with their flaws, virtues, follies, and wisdom, reflecting the complexities of modern Indian society.
While Death in Shambles may be slightly underwhelming in terms of traditional detective work, the book shines in its exploration of societal issues. It peels away the layers of the picturesque hill station, revealing the hidden secrets, corruption, and filth beneath the surface.
The story becomes a thought-provoking and occasionally witty examination of the dark underbelly of Indian society, where seemingly solid facades conceal infidelity, crooked spiritual leaders, and individuals willing to bend or break the rules to protect their reputations.
